• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Contact Us
  • Wine of the Week newsletter
  • Wine submission guidelines
Great Northwest Wine

Great Northwest Wine

News, reviews and info about the wines of Washington, Oregon, British Columbia and Idaho

  • Home
  • About us
    • Awards and honors
    • Advertising on Great Northwest Wine
    • Wine submission guidelines
  • e-edition
  • Events calendar
    • Submit an event
  • Reviews
    • Latest wine reviews
    • Wine of the Week
    • Best Buys
    • Washington wines
    • Oregon wines
    • Idaho wines
    • British Columbia wines
  • Competitions
    • Cascadia International Wine Competition
    • Idaho Wine Competition
    • “The Invite” – Great Northwest Invitational Wine Competition
    • Platinum Awards
    • Walla Walla Valley Wine Competition
    • Washington State Wine Competition
  • Explore
    • Wine news
    • Grapes and viticulture
    • Washington wine
    • Oregon wine
    • Idaho wine
    • British Columbia wine
    • Product reviews
    • Recipes
    • Podcast

Comparing California, Washington wine

February 9, 2013 by Andy Perdue 6 Comments

Washington wine
Washington competes with California on quality and value, not on size. This is The Benches Vineyard in Washington’s Horse Heaven Hills. (Photo by Andy Perdue/Great Northwest Wine)

SACRAMENTO, Calif. – On Friday, the USDA released California’s preliminary 2012 wine grape harvest numbers, and they reveal a lot of interesting information, especially when compared with Washington wine.

Overall, California crushed more than 4 million tons of wine grapes, easily outdistancing 2005’s record crop of 3.75 million tons.

The No. 1 grape was, of course, Chardonnay, making up 16.8 percent of the state’s total. In second was Cabernet Sauvignon with 11.3 percent, then Zinfandel with 10.4 percent.

Washington is No. 2 in U.S. wine production behind California. As we shall see, it is a distant No. 2.

Here is how California and Washington wine compare on a macro level:

Total tonnage in 2012:

  • California: 4,014,000
  • Washington: 188,000

Red wine grapes:

  • California: 2,290,000
  • Washington: 94,500

White wine grapes:

  • California: 1,724,000
  • Washington: 93,500

Price per ton:

  • California: $769
  • Washington: $1,040

Price per ton, red grapes:

  • California: $879
  • Washington: $1,235

Price per ton, white grapes:

  • California: $624
  • Washington: $844

It is impossible to compare California with Washington wine (or any other state) because California’s overall business model for wine is so different. As former Gov. Chris Gregoire so famously pointed out last year, Washington doesn’t make jug wine. And that is where a lot of California’s wine grapes go.

Comparing Washington wine with Napa, Sonoma

It is more important to compare Washington wine, which is in the premium category, with California’s premium regions, particularly Napa and Sonoma counties. California’s statistics lump together Sonoma and Marin counties, so that is how we’ll look at them here.

Wine grape acreage (these numbers are not reported by the USDA, so they are gleaned from other sources):

  • Napa: 43,000
  • Sonoma: 60,000
  • Washington: 43,000

Total tonnage in 2012:

  • Napa: 181,183
  • Sonoma/Marin: 266,101
  • Washington: 188,000

Red wine grapes:

  • Napa: 130,638
  • Sonoma/Marin: 161,931
  • Washington: 94,500

White wine grapes:

  • Napa: 50,544
  • Sonoma/Marin: 104,170
  • Washington: 93,500

Now let’s dive into some of the varieties.

Chardonnay tonnage:

  • Napa: 31,790
  • Sonoma/Marin: 80,879
  • Washington: 36,900

Riesling tonnage:

  • Napa: 447
  • Sonoma/Marin: 354
  • Washington: 36,700

Cabernet Sauvignon:

  • Napa: 70,934
  • Sonoma/Marin: 46,769
  • Washington: 35,900

Merlot:

  • Napa: 24,977
  • Sonoma/Marin: 21,472
  • Washington: 34,600

Sauvignon Blanc:

  • Napa: 13,787
  • Sonoma/Marin: 17,086
  • Washington: 5,100

Pinot Gris:

  • Napa: 981
  • Sonoma/Marin: 2,634
  • Washington: 6,400

What we see from all this data is that the Washington wine industry is the same size as Napa in acreage and tonnage. Because Riesling carries a higher tonnage than Cabernet Sauvignon (roughly double, in fact), Washington brings in more grapes per acre than Napa.

Napa, meanwhile, puts much of its emphasis on its world-class Cabernet Sauvignon, as it should, which is why it grows nearly twice as much.

Washington, meanwhile, is well distributed between its top four grapes, with Chardonnay, Riesling, Cab and Merlot nearly even in tonnage last year.

Sonoma/Marin is top-heavy with Chardonnay but shows more balance on the red side, with Pinot Noir No. 1 at 52,379 tons and Cab a not-too-distant No. 2.

Washington wine competes on price

Where Washington wine competes, of course, is on price. Here’s a look at those numbers:

Price per ton for all wine grapes:

  • Napa: $3,578
  • Sonoma/Marine: $2,181
  • Washington: $1,040

As has been the case for several years, Washington wine grapes are about half the price of Sonoma’s and less than a third of Napa’s. Land prices in Napa are astronomical, partly because of the region’s well-earned reputation and partly because of scarcity – little unplanted acreage is left.

California No. 1 in Riesling

One other interesting tidbit that is buried in the numbers: California crushed more Riesling last year than Washington: 36,892 tons compared with 36,700 tons. This is a huge jump from 2011, when 27,756 tons were crushed in California. The vast majority of California’s Riesling is grown in cooler Monterey and San Benito counties, where 14,803 tons were crushed last year.

Filed Under: News, Washington wine Tagged With: featured, ticker

About Andy Perdue

Andy Perdue is founding partner of Great Northwest Wine LLC and a longtime wine columnist. He is a third-generation journalist who has worked at newspapers since the mid-1980s and has been writing about wine since 1998. He co-founded Wine Press Northwest magazine with Eric Degerman and served as its editor-in-chief for 15 years. He is the author of "The Northwest Wine Guide: A Buyer's Handbook" (Sasquatch, 2003) and has contributed to four other books.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. nicolas says

    February 11, 2013 at 8:16 am

    Andy,

    Hi, where did you see the CA Riesling tonnage number? Seems high to me considering that CA reports 4,147 acres (my last data from 2011) of Riesling vs 7,864 for WA.

    Nicolas

    Reply
  2. Andy Perdue says

    February 11, 2013 at 8:35 am

    Nico,

    Yes, surprisingly high.

    I got it from the preliminary California harvest report:

    http://www.nass.usda.gov/Statistics_by_State/California/Publications/Grape_Crush/Prelim/2012/201202gcbtb00.pdf

    The Riesling tonnage is at the bottom of Page 6.

    Reply
    • Nicolas says

      February 13, 2013 at 5:03 pm

      Whao, I see that number. My acreage number comes from the state report – that would be a huge yield per acre. May be lots of Central valley Riesling gets blended away? Because we sure don’t see 2.5 million cases of CA Riesling….

      Reply
      • Andy Perdue says

        February 13, 2013 at 5:40 pm

        Nico,

        It looks like 14k or so is coming from Monterey and San Benito counties. That kind of makes sense. I wonder if this is wrong, though. It seems like too much of a jump from last year.

        Reply
        • Nicolas says

          February 14, 2013 at 8:52 am

          Yes – agreed. NASS has been wrong in the past (so have I). I am going to ask folks at Ciatti and Turrentine what they have on file – be back soon with more data.

          Reply
  3. Edward Schulz says

    February 11, 2013 at 9:41 am

    Very nicely done, reinforcing with figures what I have been sensing for years, that Washington is on track to exceed California’s premium wine production in every measurable production parameter.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Wine of the Week

Mt. Hood Winery 2018 Gunkel Vineyard Barbera, Columbia Valley $38

July 8, 2022

Latest Wine Reviews

Trella Vineyards 2016 Pinot Gris, Umpqua Valley $16

July 23, 2022 By Great Northwest Wine

Flora Jane Cellars 2021 Pinot Gris, Willamette Valley $22

July 23, 2022 By Great Northwest Wine

More Northwest Wine News

Footer

Grapes

Northwest vineyards enter August as much as 12 days behind normal

Oregon stands out throughout Pinot Gris tasting

The Wine Knows: Mastering the magical blend of GSM

Sniff, Sip, Swirl: Holmes family unveils Arneis on Red Mountain

Northwest Merlot remains memorable in talented hands

Food

Match Maker: Thiessen puts his brand on WW with Walla Walla Steak Co.

Match Maker recipe: Chocolate Crémeux Tart with Cocoa Nibs and Hazelnuts

Ellen on Wine: 19th century French chef’s legacy inspires 21st century NW women in hospitality with Les Dames d’Escoffier

Match Maker recipe: Cast Iron Cowboy Ribeye with Marinated Spring Vegetables

Expect heavy bidding as Reveal Walla Walla wine auction returns 

History

Ellen on Wine: 19th century French chef’s legacy inspires 21st century NW women in hospitality with Les Dames d’Escoffier

Kiona, Barnard Griffin toast 40th Red Mountain harvest with fundraiser Cab

Parks Redwine, owner of NorthWest Wine Summit competition, dies in Atlanta

Yakima Valley thrives as historical heart of Washington wine

Washington Wine Hall of Fame Gala raises record $105,000 for Clore Center

© 2022 Great NW Wine. All Rights Reserved.